Thursday, March 3, 2016

Outpatient Committal: “Politics and Psychiatry in a Culture of Fear”

Mad in America

Outpatient Committal: “Politics and Psychiatry in a Culture of Fear”
Around The Web October 15, 2014

Psychiatrists' use of community treatment orders (or outpatient committal) in the UK is already ten times more frequent than was originally envisioned, writes Manchester Metropolitan University's Ken McLaughlin in This is evidence, he argues, that the whole idea of community treatment orders is misguided.

"(P)sychiatric practice is still all too often directed not by advances in mental health care but by the political and cultural concerns of the day," writes McLaughlin. "The use and abuse of Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) is but one of the more recent manifestations of this process. They are reflective of a wider culture of fear and risk aversion, of a political establishment increasingly concerned with the micromanagement of community life, a process which also affects professionals who increasingly work in a risk-averse manner."

"It was initially thought that CTOs would mainly be used on patients with several psychiatric admissions, the so-called ‘revolving door’ patient phenomenon, whereby someone was admitted to hospital, got better with medication, was discharged, stopped taking the medication, relapsed, was readmitted to hospital and so on. Irrespective of this, a history of non-compliance is not necessary for a CTO to be imposed; it can be applied to a patient after a first compulsory admission for treatment provided the necessary criteria are met."

McLaughlin says that government envisaged 350-450 CTOs would be issued in England and Wales in the first year that the powers came in to force. "However, the number far exceeded the government’s and its advisers’ expectations. In the first five months in which professionals were able to issue them, November 2008 to March 2009, there were 2,134 issued in England alone." In 2012, writes McLaughlin, there were 4,764 people subject to such orders – many following their first admission to a psychiatric hospital.

Community Treatment Orders: Politics and psychiatry in a culture of fear (, October 7, 2014)
--Rob Wipond, News Editor

This entry was posted in Around The Web, Involuntary Treatment. Bookmark the Recent News

Benzodiazepine Prescriptions Increase with Overdose Deaths February 29, 2016
Latest Antidepressant a Case Study in Institutional Corruption February 27, 2016

Parents of Justina Pelletier Sue Boston Children’s Hospital February 26, 2016
Recent Blogs
Amber Gum, PhDAmber Gum, PhD

A Conversation about Having Conversations about Psychiatry March 2, 2016
Joanna Moncrieff, MD
New Research into Antipsychotic Discontinuation And Reduction: the RADAR programme March 2, 2016

John Read
The Mental Health Tribunal March 1, 2016

Around The Web

Most Drug Makers Report Incomplete Side Effects to the FDA March 2, 2016

“Big Pharma’s Animated Ads To Get FDA Scrutiny” March 2, 2016

“People with Schizophrenia Hear Voices- Their Own” March 2, 2016
Related Posts

Involuntary Mental Health Treatment Will Not Fix Anything February 10, 2015
When Is Psychiatric Treatment Like Child Abuse? September 26, 2014
Angry Caller to Help Line Tracked, Incarcerated in Psychiatric Hospital & Billed September 24, 2014

“Therapeutic” Boot Camps for Teens Still Out of ControlSeptember 11, 2014
Advocate for Outpatient Committal RecantsJuly 28, 2014
Outpatient Committal: “Politics and Psychiatry in a Culture of Fear” Comments RSS
5 thoughts on “Outpatient Committal: “Politics and Psychiatry in a Culture of Fear””

    s1w2f3 on October 15, 2014 at 12:27 pm said:
    This suggests that English psychiatry attracts people with sociopathic tendencies. As any rape councillor will admit, rape is an assault of power and control and not sex. Violating people by inducing distress and despair through drugs and disrespect must give these psychiatrists a certain “fix” of joy.
    Log in to Reply

        markps2 on October 15, 2014 at 9:19 pm said:
        “It is better one hundred innocent Persons should be found guilty and suffer (psychiatric drugs and psychiatric prison), than that one guilty Person should escape.” says Psychiatry.
        Log in to Reply

    markps2 on October 15, 2014 at 1:03 pm said:
    A CTOs doesn’t cost the psychiatrist any money. It is the taxpayers money.
    Szasz often said “cui bono/Who benefits?”
    Comedy.You have to wait until the end for the punchline. Possible unsafe language NSFW
    Log in to Reply

    Fred Abbe on October 16, 2014 at 12:03 am said:
    If someone could only compile an updated list of all the names of all the psychiatrists in the world with their home address’s and phone numbers all constantly updated and with a list of the psychiatrists who were ordering these CTO ‘s they could be called up for a friendly conversation or we could drop by maybe as unannounced lunch guests to discuss mutual concerns. I just happened to be in the neighborhood kind of thing. I brought you a a latte from Starbucks.
    Log in to Reply

    boans on October 16, 2014 at 12:10 am said:
    How often do we see this. “we need powers to deal with a small group of people who are falling through the cracks”. Powers are given in the false belief that those given the powers will not abuse them, and then hey presto, the 60 people who the powers were given to deal with turns into 6000.
    It was initially thought….. no it wasn’t but it never got discussed. The “stated aims” were false, and the “intended consequences” have now been realised.
    Having been threatened with one of these CTO’s they are nothing more than a stick for a psychiatrist to beat a person into submission with.

   Click here to join in support of Mad In America. Our ongoing operations are funded entirely by the support of our readers.

No comments:

Post a Comment